 Over the past decade much has been written about 9/11 – I focused my undergraduate dissertation on it – and there is likely to be a lot more. Over the past week there have been numerous television shows across the terrestrial channels that have each illustrated a different perspective from 9/11. The pick of the bunch for me was the ITV documentary that aired on Thursday 1st September. It covered the movements of President Bush, Vice-President Cheney, Mayor Giuliani and other senior US Government officials. From watching those images it is clear to see that they were not prepared for those attacks; just as the world was not prepared for those attacks.
Over the past decade much has been written about 9/11 – I focused my undergraduate dissertation on it – and there is likely to be a lot more. Over the past week there have been numerous television shows across the terrestrial channels that have each illustrated a different perspective from 9/11. The pick of the bunch for me was the ITV documentary that aired on Thursday 1st September. It covered the movements of President Bush, Vice-President Cheney, Mayor Giuliani and other senior US Government officials. From watching those images it is clear to see that they were not prepared for those attacks; just as the world was not prepared for those attacks. After the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Cold War there was a decade of relative global peace. Aside from the interventions in Bosnia  and Kosovo and the threat of the IRA, Britain UK  has been involved in long campaigns in Afghanistan  and Iraq Libya UK 
The force of Al-Qaeda has been felt across the globe since 2001 with attacks in Bali, Mumbai, London 
Since that world-changing day in 2001 so much has happened: the wars in Iraq  and Afghanistan ; terrorist attacks in London , Bali  and Mumbai; the killing of Osama Bin Laden; and the Arab Spring. I would like to invite you to join Generation 2 Generation and a panel of eminent speakers in London Libya , Syria  and indeed, Afghanistan 
I welcome any comments and thoughts on this topic.
Generation 2 Generation is a non-partisan, not for profit organisation which organises talks and debates on current affairs for young professionals and students which feature leading figures from politics, business and the media. It aims to be a forum where today's leaders meet tomorrow's ones. Previous speakers who have addressed us include George Parker (Political Editor, The Financial Times), Liam Fox MP (Defence Secretary) Mary Dejevsky (former Washington  and Moscow 
 
I was going to post something counterfactual, but My old friend Niall has beaten me to it. (http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2011/09/04/what-if-9-11-had-never-happened.html?fb_ref=article&fb_source=home_oneline). I am not sure I agree with his viewpoint, (it is extremely simplistic to start off with), but perhaps it is interesting to focus on the rest of the world. Would Bali, London and Madrid happened without 9/11 and the resultant 'war on terror?' Before this, did Al Qaeda see America's allies in this war as a threat, an oppressor, a right hand man to the American world system? Or did 9/11 actually make these places take sides, come out against Islamic fundamentalists, and therefore cause a clash with these places, both within their sovereign borders and internationally?
ReplyDeleteMy expertise lies somewhat outside this topic, but I think they are some interesting points to consider
Like you say, Steve, Ferguson’s article is very simplistic - but does provoke some interesting points. However, it is almost like saying, 'what would the world be like if Hitler's parents had never met?!' – Very hard to predict!!
ReplyDeleteIf 9/11 had not occurred then it is fair to say that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan would not have taken place (not so soon anyway). Even if the attacks had still occurred in London and Bali I do not believe these would have been triggers for war. 9/11 was so different because of the scale of the attacks, the fact that the targets included the principal symbol of ‘Western’ power (the Pentagon) and the ultimate symbol of 'Western' finance (the World Trade Centre). Arguably, President Bush had no choice but to retaliate in the way he did. I think 9/11 helped to cement the American allies - if you read accounts of trans-Atlantic relations pre-9/11 it can be viewed as a relationship that was becoming anything but 'special'. Without 9/11 I don’t believe Prime Minister Blair would have had so many trips the Bush’s Texas ranch.
As for Niall Ferguson’s use of survey results – of course the figures for American power will be different now. Americans have witnessed two failed wars with thousands of US servicemen and women killed and injured – that is not something I imagine they would want to go through again in a hurry. Furthermore, the US is currently witnessing its worst financial crisis for generations – American citizens will, rightly or wrongly, want to ensure that government spending is focused on the US economy and creating jobs rather than raising spending on security and defence.
The G2G event on the 28 September will debate some of these issues and especially look at the arguments for and against the success of the past decade. Some think the War on Terror has been a success: Al Qaeda is on the run; Osama Bin Laden has been killed and the Taliban was toppled in Afghanistan; Saddam Hussain's brutal regime was overthrown in Iraq; The Arab Spring has shown the Middle East's desire for freedom and democracy. Alternatively, the counter arguments to these are: Al Qaeda has not yet been destroyed; Afghanistan, Pakistan and Iraq suffer from instability and uncertainty; The Iraq War was a wrong and misguided folly; Guantanamo Bay, extraordinary rendition and alleged torture have damaged the West's reputation
Ten years on from 9/11 there are still many questions and issues still to be debated.
For more info on the G2G event visit http://g2gglobalpolitics.eventbrite.com/